Taxes

Did Governor Scott direct state employees to interfere in an election? Governor won't release records that could absolve him

Vermont Tax Commissioner Bill Shouldice hoped his election-week op-ed was “being used for debate prep”. Gov. Phil Scott's office, the Agency of Administration and the Department of Taxes are withholding their emails about it under executive privilege. Vermont has no statute like the federal Hatch Act.

MRBy Matt Rkiouak · November 20, 2026 · 7 min read
Did Governor Scott direct state employees to interfere in an election? Governor won't release records that could absolve him

The Tax Commissioner's election-week op-ed began with "a lot of enthusiasm from the 5th floor", the floor of 109 State Street where the Governor's office and the Secretary of Administration sit. On the day of the gubernatorial debate the Commissioner wrote that he hoped the op-ed was "being used for debate prep", and the fifth floor cleared it for release that morning. Did Governor Phil Scott or his staff direct state employees to produce an op-ed against his opponent's proposal in the middle of his reelection campaign? There are emails between the fifth floor and the Department of Taxes that could answer that question. This week the Scott administration told the Gazette it will not release them, citing executive privilege. If those emails showed that the Governor and his staff had no hand in directing the op-ed, releasing them would settle the question in his favor. The administration has chosen to keep them.

What the administration is withholding

On November 19 the Office of the Governor sent four pages and withheld the rest. Its records officer wrote that the withheld records include "those records between the Governor, the Governor's Senior Staff and Tax Department officials with respect to tax policy and communications strategy." On November 20 the Agency of Administration withheld everything it found. Its letter says the records include "communications involving the Governor, the Secretary of Administration, their respective senior staff, and Department of Taxes officials concerning tax policy and communications strategy." The Governor's legal counsel, Jaye Pershing Johnson, is named as responsible for that determination. The Department of Taxes, which had been holding five documents for review since November 3 and said on November 13 that they were "under review with another agency", wrote on November 19 that "The Administration asserts executive privilege with regard to two documents": an email from Secretary of Administration Sarah Clark to Commissioner Bill Shouldice and Deputy Commissioner Rebecca Sameroff dated October 14, and one from Clark to Shouldice, Amanda Wheeler, Sameroff and Jason Maulucci dated October 20. Wheeler is the Governor's press secretary. Maulucci is the Governor's director of policy. Neither the Governor's office nor the Agency of Administration listed the records it withheld.

The administration's letters describe what they withheld as communications about "tax policy and communications strategy". The op-ed itself was public: the Department posted it on its website and sent it to newspapers, and the fifth floor cleared it on the day of the debate. Why would the Governor keep his office's emails about a published op-ed from the public? What discussion of tax policy between the Governor's staff, the Secretary of Administration and his Tax Commissioner, held around a debate and in the three weeks before his election, is so sensitive that it cannot be released?

What the released records show

The earliest released record of the op-ed is from October 14. At 10:52 AM Sameroff told a Department chat: "Bill just got a lot of enthusiasm from the 5th floor for working up a wealth tax op ed." The fifth floor of 109 State Street is where the Governor's office and the Secretary of Administration sit. The Department now says the message followed the weekly "TAX/AOA Check-in" with Secretary Clark, and on November 19 it said: "The commentary was discussed at a recurring meeting." At 12:24 PM the same day the Commissioner sent his analyst ten Facebook and social-media screenshots and asked for "a master piece of an op-ed!!" The administration is withholding Clark's email to Shouldice and Sameroff from that day.

On October 19 Sameroff asked the Commissioner to "reach out to the 5th floor for a green light on the concept", adding: "I couldn't quite remember who you discussed this with besides Sec Clark." The Commissioner replied at 7:56 PM: "I pitch it to the 5th floor now!!" At 8:00 PM he sent the draft to Clark and Wheeler: "I’d love to get it out…ASAP…but let me know your thoughts!" The Governor's office cleared the draft on October 20. Wheeler wrote at 8:29 AM: "This is good to go from my perspective". The other withheld email is one Clark sent that day to Shouldice, Wheeler, Sameroff and Maulucci.

The Department released three documents on November 19: text messages between the Commissioner and his principal assistant, Sarah Mearhoff, on October 21, the day of the Vermont Public gubernatorial debate. At 11:37 AM Shouldice sent her a screenshot of his thread with a contact saved as "Amanda", shown with the initials "AW". In it, at 11:10 AM, he had written: "I hope that the Op-Ed is being used for debate prep!! Can I get the Op-Ed out?!" The reply: "Yes! Good to send anytime". To Mearhoff he added: "We are good to go…send…send…send!!" At 11:38 AM Mearhoff told the Department's op-ed group chat: "Just got the clear from 5th floor and Bill. Sending". At 3:03 PM she wrote about Calvin Cutler, a WCAX reporter: "Great news. Calvin's doing a story using our op Ed points tonight. Right before the debate". The Commissioner answered: "Let Amanda know!!!"

Governor Scott was a candidate in that debate and on the November 3 ballot. The Governor's office's own four pages include an October 6 exchange in which Wheeler takes Emma Shouldice, whose biography at her family's lobbying firm names Bill Shouldice IV, the name the Commissioner signs, as her father, off a reporter's interview request about taxing second homes and passes him to Mearhoff at the Department: "I am dropping Emma off this email – she works for the campaign which is distinct and separate from state government."

On October 21, when Mearhoff texted the Commissioner that the first paper was taking the op-ed ("Already: Waterbury Roundabout is picking it up"), he answered: "Let’s go! Here is another sound bite: To generate the $1B that Janoo is talking about by taxing 2nd homes…they would see a property tax increase of 4x…her math doesn’t work!" Amanda Janoo was the Governor's opponent in that night's debate.

The Commissioner, his deputy, his analyst and his principal assistant are state employees, paid with taxpayers' money. The State's personnel policy on political activity, Policy 5.7 of the Department of Human Resources, covers Executive Branch employees and says an employee may not "Use his or her official authority or influence for the purpose of interfering with or affecting the nomination or election of any candidate for public office" or "Engage in political activity during the employee's working hours." Under that policy, state employees may not use their offices to affect an election or work toward a candidate's election on state time. Vermont has no statute that does what the federal Hatch Act does.

What the law says about withholding records from the public

Vermont's Public Records Act exempts records that would cause the custodian "to violate any statutory or common law privilege other than the common law deliberative process privilege as it applies to the General Assembly and the Executive Branch agencies of the State of Vermont." Section 318(b)(2) requires a withholding certification to "identify the records withheld". The Department of Taxes named its two emails by date, sender and recipients. The Governor's office and the Agency of Administration gave categories.

To repeat, the State's personnel policy on political activity, Policy 5.7 of the Department of Human Resources, says an Executive Branch employee may not "Use his or her official authority or influence for the purpose of interfering with or affecting the nomination or election of any candidate for public office" or "Engage in political activity during the employee's working hours." Vermont has no statute that does what the federal Hatch Act does.

The Governor's office's withholding can be appealed to the Governor's chief of staff and the Agency of Administration's to the Secretary of Administration, and then to the Superior Court. All of this week's records are in the collection.


The Middlesex Gazette covers civic content in Middlesex, neighboring towns and the state at large. Back to the front page →

The Gazette comes free by email — a note when there's town news worth knowing. Subscribe by email →