Cover email from Baker, Will
Nov 19, 2026, 11:15 AM EST · RE: Appeal under 1 V.S.A. § 318(c)(1) — public records request of October 30, 2026
Nov 19, 2026, 11:15 AM EST · RE: Appeal under 1 V.S.A. § 318(c)(1) — public records request of October 30, 2026
From: "Baker, Will" <Will.Baker@vermont.gov>
To: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2026 16:15:59 +0000
Subject: RE: Appeal under 1 V.S.A. § 318(c)(1) — public records request of October 30, 2026
Mr. Rkiouak:
In response to your email, please see the comments below corresponding to your numbered sections:
1. As noted, we had five documents under review. They have been reviewed for executive privilege by the Administration. The Administration asserts executive privilege with regard to two documents. One is an email from Sarah Clark to Bill Shouldice and Rebecca Sameroff dated October 14, 2026, and the other is an email from Sarah Clark to Bill Shouldice, Amanda Wheeler, Rebecca Sameroff and Jason Maulucci dated October 20, 2026. Three are being produced, and are attached. All three are text messages responsive to your request between Bill Shouldice and Sarah Mearhoff. If you would like to continue your appeal with respect to the two emails, please let me know.
2. The email withheld under attorney/client privilege is under appeal with the commissioner. In reviewing that appeal, he will consider your requests.
3. The commentary was discussed at a recurring meeting. The existence of an occurring meeting itself is not responsive to your original request. However, you’ve requested it, so it is attached – Rebecca Sameroff’s recurring meeting on her calendar. Also, Bill Shouldice reports that he has no notes or agenda from this meeting.
Will Baker
From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
Sent: November 16, 2026 6:53 PM
To: TAX - Commissioner <TAX.Commissioner@vermont.gov>
Cc: Baker, Will <Will.Baker@vermont.gov>
Subject: Appeal under 1 V.S.A. § 318(c)(1) — public records request of October 30, 2026
EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
11/16/2026
Dear Commissioner Shouldice:
This is an appeal under 1 V.S.A. § 318(c)(1) from three denials of access on my public records request of October 30, 2026, which the Department's Legal Unit has been answering. Section 318(c)(1) provides: "Any denial of access by the custodian of a public record may be appealed to the head of the agency. The head of the agency shall make a written determination on an appeal within five business days after the receipt of the appeal." Mr. Baker is copied. This appeal does not withdraw the rest of the request, which Mr. Baker and I are still working through, and it does not cover the Department's other determinations on the request, which I may appeal separately.
1. The five documents under review.
The Department's response of November 3 said: "Some records are being reviewed for privileged and confidential communications and additional time under 3 V.S.A. 318(b)(5)(C) is needed. We expect to conclude review by November 13, 2026." On November 5 the Legal Unit corrected the citation to Title 1 and said there are five such documents. On November 13 it wrote: "Yes, those five documents are under review. They are under review with another agency, unfortunately I do not have an update for you at this time." No new date was given, and the agency was not named.
Section 318(b)(5) allows the time limits to be extended "by written notice to the person making the request setting forth the reasons for the extension and the date on which a determination is expected to be dispatched", and provides: "No such notice shall specify a date that would result in an extension for more than ten business days from receipt of the request". The consultation it allows "shall be conducted with all practicable speed". The request was received on October 30. Section 317(a)(1) provides: "'Business day' means a day that a public agency is open to provide services." Ten business days from receipt ended on Friday, November 13, or on Monday, November 16 if the Department was not open on Veterans' Day. The date in the Department's notice has passed with no production and no certification. Section 318(a)(2) provides: "A custodian or head of the agency who fails to comply with the applicable time limit provisions of this section shall be deemed to have denied the request or the appeal upon the expiration of the time limit."
I ask you to reverse that denial and have the five documents produced. If any of them is withheld in whole or in part, I ask for the certification § 318(b)(2) requires for each: the record withheld; the statutory basis and "a brief statement of the reasons and supporting facts for denial"; and the names and titles or positions of each person responsible for the denial. I ask that it come with your determination under § 318(c)(2). I also ask for the non-exempt portions of each under § 318(e), which provides that a public agency "shall redact the information it considers to be exempt and produce the record accompanied by an explanation of the basis for denial of the redacted information."
2. The withheld email.
One email has been withheld in full as an attorney-client communication under § 317(c)(3) and (4). The Legal Unit has said that it is between Ms. Connizzo, the Communications Director, and Mr. Baker, and that Deputy Commissioner Sameroff and Mr. Baker "are responsible for the withholding of the record." On November 3, November 5 and November 10 I asked for the date of the email and its subject, and on November 5 and November 10 also whether anyone else was copied. Those three particulars have not been given. On November 13 the Legal Unit wrote: "We have provided everything we are going to provide as far as the confidential communication. We have identified the record."
Section 318(b)(2) provides that the certification "shall: (A) identify the records withheld; (B) include the asserted statutory basis for denial and a brief statement of the reasons and supporting facts for denial". A date and a subject are the ordinary identification of an email. Section 318(e) provides that a public agency "shall not withhold any record in its entirety on the basis that it contains some exempt content if the record is otherwise subject to disclosure". I ask for the email with the information the Department considers exempt redacted, and at the least for its date, its sender and recipient lines and its subject line.
I ask you to direct that the email be produced with its exempt content redacted under § 318(e), showing the date, the sender and recipient lines and the subject line, or that the certification be completed with those particulars and the brief statement of reasons and supporting facts that § 318(b)(2)(B) provides for.
3. The calendar entry for the October 14 meeting.
On November 13 the Legal Unit wrote: "The calendar item or existence of a recurring meeting of Sameroff, Shouldice and Clark is not responsive to your request – that is why it was not produced." My request defined "communications" to include "calendar invitations and meeting notes," and items 2(b) and 3 asked for communications concerning the commentary with the Agency of Administration, including the Secretary, and within the Department. The Department's own records tie the meeting to the commentary: Ms. Sameroff's message of October 14 at 10:52 AM ("Bill just got a lot of enthusiasm from the 5th floor for working up a wealth tax op ed") and the Legal Unit's statement of November 10 that the message "was sent after the regular weekly meeting of Ms. Sameroff, Ms. Clark and Mr. Shouldice." I ask you to reverse that determination and have the calendar entry for the October 14 meeting produced, or, if it is withheld, the certification § 318(b)(2) provides for.
If you uphold any part of these denials, § 318(c)(2) provides that the written determination include the statutory basis, "a brief statement of the reasons and supporting facts for upholding the denial", and notice of the provisions for judicial review under § 319.
Thank you for your attention to this.
Sincerely,
Matt Rkiouak
Middlesex, Vermont
mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>
Part of the Gazette's published records for A political message from the Tax Department, edited and cleared by the Governor's office, days before Scott stood for reelection and The Tax Commissioner directed state employees to write an op-ed based on Facebook memes. Why doesn’t Vermont have a ‘little Hatch Act’? and Did Governor Scott direct state employees to interfere in an election? Governor won't release records that could absolve him. All 151 files →