Public records · Emails · TXT

Cover email from Baker, Will

Nov 13, 2026, 2:55 PM EST · RE: Public records request — Commissioner Shouldice's commentary of October 25–27, 2026

Source
email6 cover email
Date
Nov 13, 2026, 2:55 PM EST
From
"Baker, Will" <Will.Baker@vermont.gov>
To
Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
File
email6-cover-email.txt · 61 KB
SHA-256
9a4a97dbacd128054f2bcaba7e14746d05ea69b4e6d2415d2164933ad1a9f102
From: "Baker, Will" <Will.Baker@vermont.gov>
To: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 19:55:16 +0000
Subject:  RE: Public records request — Commissioner Shouldice's commentary of October 25–27, 2026

Hello:
In response to your paragraphs:

  1.  Yes, those five documents are under review.   They are under review with another agency, unfortunately I do not have an update for you at this time.
  2.  We have provided everything we are going to provide as far as the confidential communication.  We have identified the record.
  3.  Yes, I have sent three batches:  Nov. 3, 5 and 11.
  4.  (a)  In an effort to provide what you are asking me, and to avoid confusion when I go back to Department staff to request again, it would be helpful if you could list the subject lines of the emails you are looking for.  Then, I will have everyone search for those subject lines (notwithstanding any “re:” or “fw:”), and I can collect all the emails you are requesting.  Does that make sense?  I’d like to provide everything you are asking for without having to go back and forth further.

(b) Each person you requested searched their personal and work cell phones and indicated to me that they had done so.  If they found additional responsive records, they provided them to me and I provided them to you on November 10.  Providing written certifications by each employee is not required by the Public Records Act.
                Attached is a clearer screen shot from Jake Feldman, and the images.  Nothing is missing from the yellow thumbs up, as that is the end of the conversation related to the op ed.
                In the exchange between Bill Shouldice and Rebecca Sameroff, we’ve provided what is responsive to the commentary.  The rest is not related.
                Between Sameroff and Mearhoff, we’ve provided the messages related to the commentary.
                (c) Ms. Sameroff has no notes or agenda for the meeting on October 14.  If Mr. Shouldice has notes or agenda for that meeting, I will let you know.  The calendar item or existence of a recurring meeting of Sameroff, Shouldice and Clark is not responsive to your request – that is why it was not produced.
                (d) all documents have been produced.  While explanations of records are not required by the Public Records Act, Ms. Magnus reports that “Figure 15” refers to another report from which data was taken.
                (e) Ms. Mearhoff is no longer with the Tax Department, and her emails are no longer available to the Department.  With the help of the Vermont Agency of Digital Services, I was able to identify the emails attached.   As far as Department policies, there are no responsive records.  The Department of Taxes has records of two Standard Operating Procedures regarding correspondence and the Department’s website that were over ten years old and have been retired.  There were not active for the time period at issue.
                (f) We have provided all chats and Teams information responsive to the request.

Will Baker
From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
Sent: November 10, 2026 7:08 PM
To: Baker, Will <Will.Baker@vermont.gov>
Subject: RE: Public records request — Commissioner Shouldice's commentary of October 25–27, 2026

EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
Hi Mr. Baker,

Thank you for the reply of November 10 and the seven files with it. Thank you also for identifying the two correspondents of the withheld email. Four things, then an index of what I have received so that we can confirm we are in agreement.

1. The five documents under privilege review. Your note of November 3 said you expected the review to conclude by November 13. Your reply of November 10 does not mention it. Are the five documents still under review, and should I still expect them, or the certification for any that is withheld, by Friday, November 13? For anything withheld in full or in part, please include the certification 1 V.S.A. § 318(b)(2) requires (the record withheld, the statutory basis and reasons, the names and titles of those responsible, and notice of the right to appeal), and the non-exempt portions under § 318(e).

2. The withheld email between Ms. Connizzo and you. Three particulars from my note of November 5 are still missing: its date, whether anyone else was copied, and its subject line or, if the subject line would disclose the advice sought, a one-line description of its subject. Section 318(b)(2)(A) requires the certification to identify the record withheld. Please give those three particulars. With them I can decide whether to appeal to the Commissioner.

3. What has been sent. You write that we are in agreement on what was sent. To make sure of that, the index at the end of this email lists every attachment I have received, by delivery, in the order each email carried it, with the repeats in the November 5 re-send marked. In short: 22 and 27 attachments on November 3; 54 on November 5, of which 49 are the November 3 items again and 5 are new; 2 more on November 5; 7 on November 10. That is 112 attachments and 58 distinct items. Outside the index: one email withheld in full and five documents under review. Two items in the index, 5.6 and 5.7, were produced with the income tax data removed, as your reply says. Please confirm that this matches the Department's record of what it sent, or tell me what is missing or different. If it matches, I will treat it as the agreed list and not ask for a transmittal list again.

4. From my note of November 5, these remain open.

(a) The earlier emails quoted inside the forwarded emails (point 2 of November 5). You write: "We've provided the email threads – all text of the responsive documents." I read that as the Department's position that the threads satisfy the request for those emails. I ask the Department to reconsider, for two reasons.

First, the attachments. My request of October 30 asked for emails "with full headers and attachments," in the format in which each record is maintained (§ 316(h)–(i)). The threads carry the text of the quoted emails and not their attachments. Two examples. Commissioner Shouldice's email of October 19 at 8:00 PM to Secretary Clark and Ms. Wheeler says, "Here is the Op-Ed that we worked on over the weekend!" Ms. Mearhoff's email of October 20 at 5:08 PM to Ms. Wheeler, Mr. Maulucci, Secretary Clark and the Commissioner says, "Sending along as an attachment for your review the Department's final draft of an op-ed debunking the 'wealth tax' rhetoric that's been circulating in the state." Neither draft is in the thread, and which of the produced drafts each email carried cannot be told from the text. The Department has produced one such attachment already: the file "Wealth Tax - Op Ed_D0_Attchment from 10-19 email to Bill.docx" is, by its name, the attachment to Ms. Sameroff's email of October 19 at 4:48 PM to the Commissioner, an email that appears in the production only as quoted text. I am asking for the same for every other quoted email that carried an attachment.

Second, each quoted email is a record of its own. Each quoted email dated October 1 or later was sent or received by a Department account, so each should exist in a Department mailbox as a message of its own, with its attachments and its own header. Under § 317(b) it is "written or recorded information ... produced or acquired in the course of public agency business." Section 316(h) makes the standard electronic format "the format in which the record is maintained." For an email that is the message itself, with its header and its attachments, not a copy of its text inside a later reply. My request designated that format under § 316(i).

Please produce each quoted email dated October 1 or later as its own item, in the form in which it is kept (.msg or .eml, with its attachments), one copy from whichever Department mailbox holds it. If the Department's position is that these emails and their attachments are outside the request, or that the Act does not require them to be produced separately, please state that position in writing with the reasons, so that I can take the question to the Commissioner under § 318(c)(1). Where the Department holds one of these emails and withholds it as exempt, please certify under § 318(b)(2); where one no longer exists in any Department mailbox, please certify under § 318(b)(4). If producing them would involve staff time the Department intends to charge for, please send the estimate § 316(c) provides for before incurring it.

(b) The text messages (point 3 of November 5). Thank you for asking the eight custodians again, for naming them and the devices (work and personal phones), and for the new captures. Two things from the earlier asks remain. My request of October 30 asked each custodian to confirm in writing that personal accounts and devices were searched; please pass those confirmations on, or state for each custodian what was reported. Please also state the period each search covered (October 1 through the date of the search) and the date of the search. The new captures stop short in both threads. In the Commissioner's thread with Mr. Feldman, the date of the long message about the "wealth tax" argument is not shown; the message of Wednesday, October 28 at 8:11 AM is cut after the line "To generate $1B. You could:", and the line above it is partly covered by the message entry bar; and the other screen grabs in the stack the Commissioner shared are not shown. In the Commissioner's thread with Ms. Sameroff, a message before October 20 at 4:20 PM (ending "...spaciousness this morning!") and Ms. Sameroff's message of October 22 at 8:10 AM are cut. Please state the date of the long message, and produce the full text of the cut messages and the other images in the stack, or certify under § 318(b)(4) for any that the Department does not hold; if the Department's position is that any of them does not concern the commentary, please say which. Ms. Sameroff's captures of her thread with Ms. Mearhoff close the gap between the two captures that did not overlap; thank you. The thread as captured still begins on Thursday, October 29 at 10:05 AM and ends on Ms. Mearhoff's message beginning "But indeed no interview with Bill" with no reply shown. Please produce any messages in that thread concerning the commentary before October 29 or after that message, or certify under § 318(b)(4) that there are none.

(c) The meeting of October 14 (point 6 of November 5). Thank you for the explanation. Your answer says the responsive records have been produced. The calendar entry or invitation for the regular weekly meeting of Ms. Sameroff, Secretary Clark and the Commissioner on October 14, and any notes of that meeting, are communications as my request defines them, and none is in the production. Please produce the entry and any notes or agenda for October 14, or certify under § 318(b)(4) that none exists.

(d) The two spreadsheets. Thank you. Two questions. What is "Figure 15"? The file name refers to a figure in a document that is not in the production; please identify it. And were any other tables, queries or analyses prepared for the commentary or used to verify its figures (item 3 of my request), beyond the four spreadsheets now produced? Please produce them or certify under § 318(b)(4) that there are none. I note the right of appeal on the removed data.

(e) Items 6 and 8 of my request. For item 6, the production shows which outlets ran the commentary (Ms. Mearhoff's email of November 2 and Ms. Connizzo's message of October 27) and contains nothing from any outlet itself: no reply, acceptance or decline from an editor. For item 8 (Department policies and guidance on commentaries, the website, social media and election-period communications) nothing has been produced and nothing has been said. Please produce the outlets' replies and the item 8 records, or certify under § 318(b)(4) that none exist.

(f) Where your reply states that no further records exist (answer 5, the OOC Data Team chat; answer 8, the check-in between Ms. Weinstein and Ms. Connizzo), I take the statement as the Department's certification under § 318(b)(4). If that is not how it is meant, please say so. Answer 5 covers the OOC Data Team chat; my note of November 5 also asked about any other Teams chat or channel concerning the commentary, and whether each custodian's chats and channels were searched for the period. Please answer for those as well.

Thank you for the prompt replies.

Matt Rkiouak
Middlesex, Vermont
mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>

Index of records received

Delivery 1 — Tuesday, November 3, 8:24 PM, reply on the request thread
22 attachments:
1.1 image_123655411 (4).JPG
1.2 image_123655411.JPG
1.3 MS Teams social-post-approval-not-posted.png
1.4 Op Ed Group - Teams Chat.docx
1.5 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_19 1.png
1.6 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 1.png
1.7 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 2.png
1.8 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 3.png
1.9 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 4.png
1.10 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 5.png
1.11 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 1.png
1.12 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 2.png
1.13 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 3.png
1.14 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 4.png
1.15 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 5.png
1.16 Frequency of High Income.xlsx
1.17 forwarded email: "FW: Op ed published!", Mearhoff, Sarah to Baker, Will, Nov 2, 3:48 PM
1.18 forwarded email: "FW: Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to Baker, Will, Nov 2, 3:48 PM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx)
1.19 image_123650291 (1).JPG
1.20 image_123650291 (2).JPG
1.21 image_123650291.JPG
1.22 image_123655411 (3).JPG

Delivery 2 — Tuesday, November 3, 8:24 PM, "Email 2"
27 attachments:
2.1 Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26 (1).docx
2.2 Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26 (2).docx
2.3 Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx [same bytes as 2.1]
2.4 Shouldice 'wealth tax' op ed TRUNCATED Oct 2026.docx
2.5 VT vs MA income tax liabilities_2026.xlsx
2.6 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_D0.docx
2.7 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_D0_A.docx
2.8 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_D0_Attchment from 10-19 email to Bill.docx [same bytes as 2.6]
2.9 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_draft ....agh reorg.docx
2.10 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_draft 1 marked up.docx
2.11 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_draft 1.docx
2.12 forwarded email: "Op ed published!", Mearhoff, Sarah to Shouldice, Bill, Sameroff, Rebecca, Connizzo, Katelyn, Feldman, Jake, Nov 2, 10:32 AM
2.13 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to Addison Independent, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 12:12 PM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx)
2.14 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to waterburyroundabout@gmail.com<mailto:waterburyroundabout@gmail.com>, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 11:52 AM (attachment: Shouldice op ed Oct 26.docx)
2.15 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to voices@commonsnews.org<mailto:voices@commonsnews.org>, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 11:55 AM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx)
2.16 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to waterburyroundabout@gmail.com<mailto:waterburyroundabout@gmail.com>, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 11:52 AM (attachment: Shouldice op ed Oct 26.docx) [same email as 2.14]
2.17 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to opinion@vtdigger.org<mailto:opinion@vtdigger.org>, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 11:45 AM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx)
2.18 forwarded email: "RE: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed", Sameroff, Rebecca to Shouldice, Bill, cc Feldman, Jake, Oct 19, 8:31 PM
2.19 forwarded email: "RE: Internal FW: Calvin request", Sameroff, Rebecca to Connizzo, Katelyn, Feldman, Jake, Oct 30, 3:13 PM
2.20 forwarded email: "RE: Shouldice- Wealth Tax Op-Ed", Sameroff, Rebecca to Magnus, Abigail, Feldman, Jake, Oct 20, 11:23 AM
2.21 forwarded email: "Re: clarification from Miles Trinidad", Sorsha Anderson to Sameroff, Rebecca, cc Emilie Kornheiser, Feldman, Jake, Oct 15, 5:10 PM
2.22 forwarded email: "RE: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed", Sameroff, Rebecca to Shouldice, Bill, cc Feldman, Jake, Oct 19, 8:31 PM [same email as 2.18]
2.23 forwarded email: "RE: Please review: 'wealth tax' op ed", Mearhoff, Sarah to Shouldice, Bill, Oct 27, 12:41 PM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx)
2.24 forwarded email: "RE: Shouldice- Wealth Tax Op-Ed", Sameroff, Rebecca to Magnus, Abigail, Feldman, Jake, Oct 20, 11:23 AM [same email as 2.20]
2.25 forwarded email: "Reminder to review at check in FW: Internal FW: Calvin request", Sameroff, Rebecca to Connizzo, Katelyn, Nov 2, 9:45 AM
2.26 Screenshot 2026-11-02 155404.png
2.27 Screenshot 2026-11-02 155423.png

Delivery 3 — Thursday, November 5, 4:20 PM, re-send ("I count 54 attachments")
54 attachments:
3.1 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to waterburyroundabout@gmail.com<mailto:waterburyroundabout@gmail.com>, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 11:52 AM (attachment: Shouldice op ed Oct 26.docx) [same email as 2.14]
3.2 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to voices@commonsnews.org<mailto:voices@commonsnews.org>, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 11:55 AM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx) [same email as 2.15]
3.3 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to waterburyroundabout@gmail.com<mailto:waterburyroundabout@gmail.com>, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 11:52 AM (attachment: Shouldice op ed Oct 26.docx) [same email as 2.14]
3.4 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to opinion@vtdigger.org<mailto:opinion@vtdigger.org>, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 11:45 AM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx) [same email as 2.17]
3.5 forwarded email: "RE: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed", Sameroff, Rebecca to Shouldice, Bill, cc Feldman, Jake, Oct 19, 8:31 PM [same email as 2.18]
3.6 forwarded email: "RE: Internal FW: Calvin request", Sameroff, Rebecca to Connizzo, Katelyn, Feldman, Jake, Oct 30, 3:13 PM [same email as 2.19]
3.7 forwarded email: "RE: Shouldice- Wealth Tax Op-Ed", Sameroff, Rebecca to Magnus, Abigail, Feldman, Jake, Oct 20, 11:23 AM [same email as 2.20]
3.8 forwarded email: "Re: clarification from Miles Trinidad", Sorsha Anderson to Sameroff, Rebecca, cc Emilie Kornheiser, Feldman, Jake, Oct 15, 5:10 PM [same email as 2.21]
3.9 forwarded email: "RE: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed", Sameroff, Rebecca to Shouldice, Bill, cc Feldman, Jake, Oct 19, 8:31 PM [same email as 2.18]
3.10 forwarded email: "RE: Please review: 'wealth tax' op ed", Mearhoff, Sarah to Shouldice, Bill, Oct 27, 12:41 PM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx) [same email as 2.23]
3.11 forwarded email: "RE: Shouldice- Wealth Tax Op-Ed", Sameroff, Rebecca to Magnus, Abigail, Feldman, Jake, Oct 20, 11:23 AM [same email as 2.20]
3.12 forwarded email: "Reminder to review at check in FW: Internal FW: Calvin request", Sameroff, Rebecca to Connizzo, Katelyn, Nov 2, 9:45 AM [same email as 2.25]
3.13 Screenshot 2026-11-02 155404.png [same as 2.26]
3.14 Screenshot 2026-11-02 155423.png [same as 2.27]
3.15 Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26 (1).docx [same as 2.1]
3.16 Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26 (2).docx [same as 2.2]
3.17 Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx [same as 2.1]
3.18 Shouldice 'wealth tax' op ed TRUNCATED Oct 2026.docx [same as 2.4]
3.19 VT vs MA income tax liabilities_2026.xlsx [same as 2.5]
3.20 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_D0.docx [same as 2.6]
3.21 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_D0_A.docx [same as 2.7]
3.22 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_D0_Attchment from 10-19 email to Bill.docx [same as 2.6]
3.23 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_draft ....agh reorg.docx [same as 2.9]
3.24 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_draft 1 marked up.docx [same as 2.10]
3.25 Wealth Tax - Op Ed_draft 1.docx [same as 2.11]
3.26 Connizzo MS Teams Chat 10-26.png
3.27 Connizzo MS Teams Chat 10-27-social-post-not-posted.png
3.28 Connizzo MS Teams Chat 10-28-1.png
3.29 Connizzo MS Teams Chat 10-28-2.png
3.30 Connizzo MS Teams Chat 10-29.png
3.31 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_19 1.png [same as 1.5]
3.32 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 1.png [same as 1.6]
3.33 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 2.png [same as 1.7]
3.34 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 3.png [same as 1.8]
3.35 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 4.png [same as 1.9]
3.36 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_20 5.png [same as 1.10]
3.37 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 1.png [same as 1.11]
3.38 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 2.png [same as 1.12]
3.39 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 3.png [same as 1.13]
3.40 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 4.png [same as 1.14]
3.41 Feldman MS Teams Chat 10_21 5.png [same as 1.15]
3.42 Frequency of High Income.xlsx [same as 1.16]
3.43 forwarded email: "FW: Op ed published!", Mearhoff, Sarah to Baker, Will, Nov 2, 3:48 PM [same email as 1.17]
3.44 forwarded email: "FW: Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to Baker, Will, Nov 2, 3:48 PM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx) [same email as 1.18]
3.45 image_123650291 (1).JPG [same as 1.19]
3.46 image_123650291 (2).JPG [same as 1.20]
3.47 image_123650291.JPG [same as 1.21]
3.48 image_123655411 (3).JPG [same as 1.22]
3.49 image_123655411 (4).JPG [same as 1.1]
3.50 image_123655411.JPG [same as 1.2]
3.51 MS Teams social-post-approval-not-posted.png [same as 1.3]
3.52 Op Ed Group - Teams Chat.docx [same as 1.4]
3.53 forwarded email: "Op ed published!", Mearhoff, Sarah to Shouldice, Bill, Sameroff, Rebecca, Connizzo, Katelyn, Feldman, Jake, Nov 2, 10:32 AM [same email as 2.12]
3.54 forwarded email: "Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice", Mearhoff, Sarah to Addison Independent, cc Shouldice, Bill, Oct 21, 12:12 PM (attachment: Shouldice wealth tax op ed Oct 26.docx) [same email as 2.13]

Delivery 4 — Thursday, November 5, 4:24 PM, "Two additional records"
2 attachments:
4.1 Fall 2026 Op-Ed-1-V1.png
4.2 Magnus MS Teams Chat 10_13.png

Delivery 5 — Tuesday, November 10, 3:23 PM, reply to my note of November 5
7 attachments:
5.1 Screenshot 2026-11-05 at 1.07.35 PM.png
5.2 Screenshot 2026-11-05 at 1.14.49 PM.png
5.3 Sameroff Shouldice texts 10 20 26.docx
5.4 Sameroff Mearhoff from Sameroff phone.docx
5.5 Connizzo MS Teams Chat 10-26-2.png (messages dated October 27)
5.6 Income Stats - filer data removed.xlsx
5.7 Copy of Figure 15 Data - high income filers - filer data removed.xlsx

Top-level attachments received: 112; distinct items: 58.

On Tue, Nov 10, 2026 03:24 PM, "Baker, Will" <Will.Baker@vermont.gov<mailto:Will.Baker@vermont.gov>> wrote:
Mr. Rkiouak:  In response to the numbered paragraphs in your email:


  1.  It is an email between Kathryn Connizzo, Communications Director, and myself.  It is an attorney/client communication.
  2.  We’ve provided the email threads – all text of the responsive documents.
  3.  I again requested to Mr. Shouldice, Ms. Sameroff, Ms. Mearoff, Mr. Feldman, Ms. Connizzo, Ms. Magnus, Ms. Weinstein and Ms. Shepard to review and produce all texts (personal or work phone) responsive to the commentary.  Everyone has indicated that they searched.  In addition to what was previously sent, I include the Mearoff/Sameroff texts from Ms. Sameroff’s phone.  Perhaps they will be easier to follow.  I also include two screenshots of texts from Bill Shouldice to Jake Feldman and two screen shots of texts from Bill Shouldice to Rebecca Sameroff that were identified.
  4.  I believe we are in agreement on what was sent.  The Department declines to create a transmittal list.
  5.  The 10/14 message was the only message in the OOC Data Team Chat from 10/1 to date related to the commentary.
  6.  We’ve produced the responsive records.  While not required by the Public Records Act, in response:  Ms. Sameroff’s October 14 message was sent after the regular weekly meeting of Ms. Sameroff, Ms. Clark and Mr. Shouldice.
  7.  We’ve produced the records and everything required by the Public Records Act.  While not required, in response:  I was the other participant and no, there was no response.
  8.  There are no responsive records from a check-in between Ms. Weinstein and Ms. Connizzo.  “Cal rec” refers to the Caledonian Record, a news publication.   We identified one more responsive record, attached, where Ms. Connizzo says to Ms. Weinstein on 10/27 at 4:15PM, “Can you add this to the list of outlets…”, attached.
Finally, two additional spreadsheets are attached.  They weren’t used in the commentary, but they were used to verify information.  Income tax data has been removed from these files as it is confidential tax data, and exempt from disclosure under 1 VSA 317(c)(1) and (6).  Because information was withheld, you have the right to appeal this decision to the Commissioner of Taxes under 1 VSA 318.

Will Baker

From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>>
Sent: November 05, 2026 7:03 PM
To: Baker, Will <Will.Baker@vermont.gov<mailto:Will.Baker@vermont.gov>>
Subject: RE: Public records request — Commissioner Shouldice's commentary of October 25–27, 2026

EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
Hi Mr. Baker,

Thank you for the two emails of November 5. I have the re-sent set of 54 attachments and the two additional records. Checked by file hash against the November 3 production, the re-send adds five files that were not in it, all captures of Ms. Connizzo's Teams chats (10-26, 10-27-social-post-not-posted, 10-28-1, 10-28-2 and 10-29); every other file is byte-identical to one already received. So the count is reconciled at 54, plus the two records of your second email. Thank you also for the corrected citation.

Four things remain open from my note of November 3, and the new records raise four more; point 9 is a note on scope. Points 2 and 5 through 8 are requests for records: please produce them; where an item is withheld, say so with the certification described in point 1; where it is one of the five documents under privilege review, say which point it answers and include the certification when the review concludes on November 13; where a record does not exist, certify that under § 318(b)(4).

1. The withheld email. You have identified it as an email between a Department employee and you, withheld by Deputy Commissioner Sameroff and yourself under 1 V.S.A. § 317(c)(3) and (4). Section 318(b)(2)(A) and (B) require the certification to identify the record withheld and state the supporting facts, and § 318(e) requires the non-exempt portions of a record to be produced. For the withheld email, please give its date, the name and title of the Department employee, anyone copied, and its subject line (or, if the subject line itself would disclose the advice sought, a one-line description of its subject), either in the certification or by producing the email with the privileged content redacted, so that I can decide whether to appeal to the Commissioner under § 318(c).

2. Request #5 of November 3, restated. Sixteen of the emails produced are forwards whose bodies quote earlier messages, 45 by my count, instead of attaching them. A quoted copy shows only the From/Sent/To/Subject block as the forwarder's mail program printed it; it does not carry the message's own attachments, its full recipient list as sent, or its transmission headers. In plain terms: each email in a thread is its own record. I have the last reply in each thread; I am asking for every earlier email quoted in a produced email, as a record in its own right, in the format in which it is maintained (§ 316(h)–(i)), which for an Exchange mailbox is an .msg or .eml file per message with its attachments, one copy of each from whichever Department mailbox holds it. Three examples: Commissioner Shouldice's email to Secretary Clark and Ms. Wheeler, cc Ms. Sameroff, of October 19 at 8:00 PM, with the draft it attached; Secretary Clark's reply of October 20 at 7:36 AM; Ms. Wheeler's reply of October 20 at 8:29 AM. Each was sent or received by a Department account and so should exist as its own message in a Department mailbox; please certify under § 318(b)(4) any that can no longer be found.

3. The text messages. I take it the thread between Ms. Mearhoff and Ms. Sameroff covers other matters as well, and that screenshots of the responsive stretch were the practical way to produce it rather than an export of the whole thread. On that footing I withdraw the request for an export. You say you have asked each of those individuals to search work and personal phones and confirm; thank you. When their responses come, please pass each one on, or state what each reported (Toensing v. Attorney General, 2017 VT 99, ¶ 36: the response and brief explanation of the manner of searching): who searched, the period searched (October 1 to the date of the search), the devices and accounts, and that everything responsive has been produced. By "those individuals" I mean the custodians named in my note of November 3: Commissioner Shouldice, Ms. Sameroff, Ms. Mearhoff, Mr. Feldman, Ms. Connizzo, Ms. Magnus, Ms. Weinstein and Ms. Shepard. For the Mearhoff–Sameroff thread, the captures begin at "Thursday 10:05 AM", which I take to be October 29; two of them do not overlap; and the last ends on Ms. Mearhoff's message with no reply shown. Please produce any responsive messages before, between or after what was captured, or certify under § 318(b)(4) that there are none.

4. A transmittal list would help: item number, file name, custodian, and the item of my October 30 request (1–9) it answers. The Act does not require one; with 56 files in hand it is the shortest route to agreeing what has and has not been produced before November 13. If the Department keeps no such list, a sentence naming the custodians whose accounts and devices were searched, and for which items, would do.

5. The "OOC Data Team" chat (your file "Magnus MS Teams Chat 10_13.png"; the capture's date divider reads October 14). Ms. Sameroff's 10:52 AM message in it is the earliest record of the commentary in the production, and no other message from that chat has been produced. Every message in that chat, and in any other Teams chat or channel, concerning the commentary from October 1 onward is responsive to item 3 (and to item 2 if anyone outside the Department took part). Please produce those messages, as an export or dated captures, or certify under § 318(b)(4) that the October 14 message is the only one, and confirm that each custodian's Teams chats and channels were searched for the period.

6. The fifth floor before October 19. Ms. Sameroff's October 14 message records that the Commissioner "just got a lot of enthusiasm from the 5th floor for working up a wealth tax op ed." No record of that exchange has been produced, and the earliest produced email between the Department and the Governor's office or the Agency of Administration concerning the commentary is the Commissioner's of October 19 at 8:00 PM. Any email, message, calendar entry or notes of the Department's contact with either office about the commentary from October 1 through October 19 falls under item 2(a) and (b), and any internal email about it under item 3. Please produce them, or certify under § 318(b)(4) that none exists; if the contact was in person or by phone, please say so.

7. Ms. Connizzo's chat of October 28. The 2:49 PM capture shows her message "Hi Will - Are you around?" and the link to the posted commentary, and nothing else: not the recipient, not any reply. Please produce the rest of that conversation with the chat header showing its participants, or state that there was no reply; if any part is withheld as privileged, please say so with the certification described in point 1.

8. The social post. The chats show the post held on October 28 at 6:23 PM and, on October 29 at 9:30 AM, the decision not to put out the posts, with the explanation left to a "check in". Any record of that decision (an email, a Teams message, a calendar entry or notes of the check-in) is responsive to item 5 and, if the decision followed a legal or communications review, item 7. Please produce it or certify under § 318(b)(4) that none exists. Ms. Weinstein's question of October 26, "Is that the one that was in the cal rec?", refers to something I cannot identify from the records; if it is a document, calendar entry or list that mentions the commentary, it is responsive to item 5; please produce it or say what it is. Please also produce any other messages in the Connizzo–Weinstein chat concerning the commentary between October 1 and the date of your search, or state that the four days captured are all of them.

9. For completeness: the Governor's office has a separate request from me, acknowledged October 30; nothing in this note asks you for that office's records. The Department's own copies of its exchanges with that office and with the Agency of Administration are Department records and are asked for in points 2 and 6.

On the privilege review, thank you for the count. When the five documents are released or withheld on November 13, please include for anything withheld the certification described in point 1, and the non-exempt portions of any document withheld in part, as § 318(e) requires.

Regards,


Matt Rkiouak
Middlesex, Vermont
mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>

On Thu, Nov 05, 2026 04:21 PM, "Baker, Will" <Will.Baker@vermont.gov<mailto:Will.Baker@vermont.gov>> wrote:
Mr. Rkiouak:

Attached are all the files I intended to send to you the earlier this week.  I count 54 attachments.  It’s possible some were missed previously.  If the flow of the text messages screen shots doesn’t make sense, let me know.
My apologies – I meant to cite Title 1 not Title 3.
One record was withheld.  It is an attorney-client communication and is confidential and exempt from disclosure under 1 V.S.A. § 317(c)(3),(4).  It is an email between a Department of Taxes employee and me containing attorney-client communications.  Deputy Commissioner Rebecca Sameroff and I are responsible for the withholding of the record.
As far as your requests in number 4 and 5, below, I will send you another email with the Teams approval document you requested so as not to confuse my document count above.  I have asked each of those individuals to search text messages on work and personal cellphones and confirm.  I don’t understand what you are asking for in the rest of your request #5.
There are five documents under privilege review.

Will Baker

Will S. Baker | Assistant Attorney General
Director, Legal Unit
Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State Street | Montpelier, VT  05633-1401
p:  (802) 522-3360 | www.tax.vermont.gov<http://www.tax.vermont.gov/>


CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email may contain confidential tax information. The information is intended only for use by the individual or entity addressee. If you are not the intended recipient, you are prohibited from any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action in reliance on the contents of this information, and any such action would subject you to civil and/or criminal prosecution under state and Federal confidentiality laws. If you received this email in error, immediately delete this email and contact us at (802) 522-3360 or will.baker@vermont.gov<mailto:will.baker@vermont.gov> for further instructions.



From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>>
Sent: November 03, 2026 9:16 PM
To: Baker, Will <Will.Baker@vermont.gov<mailto:Will.Baker@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Public records request — Commissioner Shouldice's commentary of October 25–27, 2026

EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
Hi Mr. Baker,

Thank you for the production of November 3. I received two emails from you at 8:24 PM, the reply on this thread with 22 attachments and a second email titled "Email 2" with 27 attachments, 49 attachments in all. Your note says 54 items. Before I treat this tranche as complete I would like to reconcile the count and ask about the text messages.

1. The count. I count 49 attachments: in the first email, 6 iPhone screenshots, 12 Teams screenshots, one Word file that contains 29 pasted Teams screenshots and no text, one spreadsheet and two forwarded emails; in the second, 10 Word drafts, one spreadsheet, two Teams screenshots and 14 forwarded emails. Seven more Word files arrive as attachments to the forwarded emails, and several files are byte-identical copies under different names (the October 26 op-ed file appears six times). Does "54 items" count attachments to forwarded emails, duplicate copies or the embedded screenshots, or is a further email with the remaining five items still to come?

2. A transmittal list. Please send a list of the 54 items by item number, file name, the custodian whose account or device it came from, and the request item or items (1–9) it responds to. That is the simplest way for both of us to confirm what has been produced, what is pending and what is withheld.

3. The withheld record. Your note cites "3 V.S.A. 317(c)". The Public Records Act exemptions are in 1 V.S.A. § 317(c). Please identify the subdivision relied on and, as 1 V.S.A. § 318(b)(2) requires, identify the record (date, sender, recipients, subject) and the names and titles of the persons responsible for withholding it.

4. The text messages. The six iPhone screenshots are one exchange between Ms. Mearhoff and Ms. Sameroff, captured on Ms. Mearhoff's phone at 3:20 and beginning at "Thursday 10:05 AM", which I read as October 29. The capture is incomplete in three places: it ends mid-conversation with Ms. Mearhoff's message "But indeed no interview with Bill (despite his eagerness...)" and shows no reply; two of the screenshots do not overlap, so messages may be missing between "...objective fact-checking in this conversation!" and "Hey so this Calvin message..."; and nothing before October 29 is produced although the request period began October 1. Please produce the complete exchange from October 1 through the date of your search, including messages after the last one captured, in the format in which it is maintained (1 V.S.A. § 316(h)–(i)), which for a phone is a message export rather than screenshots; if screenshots are the only option, please have them overlap and state the date of capture. Please also confirm whether Ms. Sameroff's copy of the same thread was searched, and whether text messages of the other custodians the production identifies (Commissioner Shouldice, Mr. Feldman, Ms. Connizzo, Ms. Magnus, Ms. Weinstein and Ms. Shepard) were searched. My request asked each custodian to confirm in writing that personal accounts and devices were searched (Toensing v. Attorney General, 2017 VT 99); no confirmation accompanied the production.

5. Two items the production refers to but does not include. The Teams Approvals card for "Bill op-ed" (requested by Ms. Weinstein and approved by Ms. Sameroff on October 28) attaches a graphic, "Fall 2026 Op-Ed-1-V1.png", on SharePoint; please produce it under item 5. The forwarded emails quote some 45 earlier messages in their bodies, including messages from Amanda Wheeler and Sarah Clark on October 20; where those earlier messages exist as separate items in a custodian's mailbox, please produce them as such, with headers.

6. The pending review. You expect to finish the privilege review by November 13. Please say how many records are in that review, so that the final count can be reconciled against the transmittal list.

Thank you for the prompt response.

Matt Rkiouak
Middlesex, Vermont
mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>




---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Mearhoff, Sarah" <Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov>>
To: "waterburyroundabout@gmail.com<mailto:waterburyroundabout@gmail.com>" <waterburyroundabout@gmail.com<mailto:waterburyroundabout@gmail.com>>
Cc: "Shouldice, Bill" <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Bcc:
Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 15:52:44 +0000
Subject: Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice
Hi there – I hope you’re well.

I’m reaching out with an op-ed (attached) by Vermont Tax Department Commissioner Bill Shouldice for the Roundabout’s publication consideration.

On a subsequent page in the Word document is a “source” sheet with source material and methodology from the Tax Department to assist in your fact-checking.

Please feel free to reach out to me with follow-up questions throughout your editing process.

I look forward to hearing from you. Thank you!

Sarah Mearhoff | Principal Assistant
Office of the Commissioner | Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State Street | Montpelier, VT 05633-1401
Tel. [phone redacted]

This email may contain confidential tax information. The information is intended only for use by the individual or entity addressee. If you are not the intended recipient, you are prohibited from any disclosure, copying, distribution, or the taking of any action in reliance on the contents of this information, and any such action would subject you to civil and/or criminal prosecution under State and Federal confidentiality laws. If you received this email in error, immediately delete this email and contact us at [phone redacted] or sarah.mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:sarah.mearhoff@vermont.gov> for further instructions.




---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Mearhoff, Sarah" <Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov>>
To: "voices@commonsnews.org<mailto:voices@commonsnews.org>" <voices@commonsnews.org<mailto:voices@commonsnews.org>>
Cc: "Shouldice, Bill" <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Bcc:
Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 15:55:05 +0000
Subject: Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice
Hi there – I hope you’re well.

I’m reaching out with an op-ed (attached) by Vermont Tax Department Commissioner Bill Shouldice for The Commons’ publication consideration.

On a subsequent page in the Word document is a “source” sheet with source material and methodology from the Tax Department to assist in your fact-checking.

Please feel free to reach out to me with follow-up questions throughout your editing process.

I look forward to hearing from you. Thank you!

Sarah Mearhoff | Principal Assistant
Office of the Commissioner | Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State Street | Montpelier, VT 05633-1401
Tel. [phone redacted]

This email may contain confidential tax information. The information is intended only for use by the individual or entity addressee. If you are not the intended recipient, you are prohibited from any disclosure, copying, distribution, or the taking of any action in reliance on the contents of this information, and any such action would subject you to civil and/or criminal prosecution under State and Federal confidentiality laws. If you received this email in error, immediately delete this email and contact us at [phone redacted] or sarah.mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:sarah.mearhoff@vermont.gov> for further instructions.




---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Mearhoff, Sarah" <Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov>>
To: "waterburyroundabout@gmail.com<mailto:waterburyroundabout@gmail.com>" <waterburyroundabout@gmail.com<mailto:waterburyroundabout@gmail.com>>
Cc: "Shouldice, Bill" <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Bcc:
Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 15:52:44 +0000
Subject: Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice
Hi there – I hope you’re well.

I’m reaching out with an op-ed (attached) by Vermont Tax Department Commissioner Bill Shouldice for the Roundabout’s publication consideration.

On a subsequent page in the Word document is a “source” sheet with source material and methodology from the Tax Department to assist in your fact-checking.

Please feel free to reach out to me with follow-up questions throughout your editing process.

I look forward to hearing from you. Thank you!

Sarah Mearhoff | Principal Assistant
Office of the Commissioner | Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State Street | Montpelier, VT 05633-1401
Tel. [phone redacted]

This email may contain confidential tax information. The information is intended only for use by the individual or entity addressee. If you are not the intended recipient, you are prohibited from any disclosure, copying, distribution, or the taking of any action in reliance on the contents of this information, and any such action would subject you to civil and/or criminal prosecution under State and Federal confidentiality laws. If you received this email in error, immediately delete this email and contact us at [phone redacted] or sarah.mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:sarah.mearhoff@vermont.gov> for further instructions.




---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Mearhoff, Sarah" <Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov>>
To: "opinion@vtdigger.org<mailto:opinion@vtdigger.org>" <opinion@vtdigger.org<mailto:opinion@vtdigger.org>>
Cc: "Shouldice, Bill" <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Bcc:
Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 15:45:57 +0000
Subject: Op-ed from Tax Commissioner Shouldice
Hi there – I hope you’re well.

I’m reaching out with an op-ed (attached) by Vermont Tax Department Commissioner Bill Shouldice for VTDigger’s publication consideration.

On a subsequent page in the Word document is a “source” sheet with source material and methodology from the Tax Department to assist in your fact-checking.

Please feel free to reach out to me with follow-up questions throughout your editing process.

I look forward to hearing from you. Thank you!

Sarah Mearhoff | Principal Assistant
Office of the Commissioner | Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State Street | Montpelier, VT 05633-1401
Tel. [phone redacted]

This email may contain confidential tax information. The information is intended only for use by the individual or entity addressee. If you are not the intended recipient, you are prohibited from any disclosure, copying, distribution, or the taking of any action in reliance on the contents of this information, and any such action would subject you to civil and/or criminal prosecution under State and Federal confidentiality laws. If you received this email in error, immediately delete this email and contact us at [phone redacted] or sarah.mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:sarah.mearhoff@vermont.gov> for further instructions.




---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Sameroff, Rebecca" <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
To: "Shouldice, Bill" <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Cc: "Feldman, Jake" <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Bcc:
Date: Tue, 20 Oct 2026 00:31:04 +0000
Subject: RE: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed
Freudian slip!

From: Shouldice, Bill <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Monday, October 19, 2026 7:56 PM
To: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
Cc: Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Re: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed

*smart ass

Bill Shouldice IV
Commissioner
Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State Street, Montpelier VT 05633
802.828.3763
[signatureImage]

________________________________
From: Shouldice, Bill <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Monday, 19 October 2026 19:56:01
To: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
Cc: Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Re: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed

This is awesome!!

Jake you are a bit of a smarts, but you have captured my voice and my self deprecating humor.

I pitch it to the 5th floor now!!


Bill Shouldice IV
Commissioner
Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State Street, Montpelier VT 05633
802.828.3763
[signatureImage]

________________________________
From: Shouldice, Bill <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Monday, 19 October 2026 19:48:33
To: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
Cc: Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Re: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed

Thanks….reading it now.

I’ll share my thoughts in the morning

Jake…I really appreciate it!

Bill Shouldice IV
Commissioner
Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State Street, Montpelier VT 05633
802.828.3763
[signatureImage]

________________________________
From: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Monday, 19 October 2026 16:48:53
To: Shouldice, Bill <Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov<mailto:Bill.Shouldice@vermont.gov>>
Cc: Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Subject: FW: Draft Wealth Tax Op-ed


Hey Bill!



Jake did a GREAT first pass at op-ed content over the weekend. Sarah M wasn’t (yet) successful at getting Amanda Wheeler’s ear today, so I was hoping you could reach out to the 5th floor for a green light on the concept before we ask Jake and comms colleagues to dig into making improvements and incorporating any feedback from you. (I couldn’t quite remember who you discussed this with besides Sec Clark.)



Wild week with the symposium so I want to be strategic!



Looking forward to next steps!

R



---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Sameroff, Rebecca" <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
To: "Connizzo, Katelyn" <Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov<mailto:Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov>>, "Feldman, Jake" <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Cc:
Bcc:
Date: Fri, 30 Oct 2026 19:13:52 +0000
Subject: RE: Internal FW: Calvin request
Ah great point Kate – we only need to address Calvin’s question. However, it feels like a half story without noting the inaccuracy of the claim that some folks are seeing a huge cut this year from OBBBA. Reframed it below as a response to PAI’s complaint that Calvin received. How do folks feel about that?

Like the commissioner inbox strategy and then if he needs more discussion we could talk about who’s best positioned at that point….

Jake I added some additional content to help a layman follow the argument. Can you reread and make any suggested edits if I muddied things? I’m sorry I had the changes in red but accidentally pasted some formatting and lost them! The third bullet got the biggest facelift. Little additions elsewhere.

Hi Calvin,

Happy to provide some background regarding the legislature’s 2018 income tax reform.


  *   In Act 11 of 2018, in response to the federal Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, the Legislature made Vermont's income tax more progressive, increasing taxes on filers with income over $100,000 by about $11M and decreasing taxes on filers under that by about $9M. A former analyst from the Joint Fiscal Office, Graham Campbell, who served the House Ways and Means (HWM) Committee during this chapter, testified<https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20Ways%20and%20Means/Bills/DR%2026-0804/W~Graham%20Campbell~Tax%20Cut%20and%20Jobs%20Act,%20Retrospective%20and%20Lessons~4-21-2026.pdf#page=5> to that effect this past spring.


  *   Part of the justification for the tax increase at that time was the understanding that the federal income taxes of the highest earning Vermonters were decreasing as a result of the TCJA. The tax impacts of the TCJA varied based on each taxpayer’s circumstances, but in many cases the new $10,000 federal limitation on the federal state and local income tax deduction (the "SALT" deduction) generated tax increases that outstripped the tax savings from the lower marginal rates. This was especially true in high tax states like Vermont. We explained<https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2018/WorkGroups/Senate%20Finance/Bills/H.911/H.911~Jake%20Feldman~Impacts%20to%20Vermont%20Taxpayers%20of%20the%20Tax%20Cuts%20and%20Jobs%20Act~4-6-2018.pdf> that and showed the math in committee


  *   Public Assets is a member of the Fair Share for Vermont Coalition<https://fairsharevt.org/release-jan28-2026> whose policy position on income tax reform is based on an inaccurate characterization of the tax changes in H.R.1. The Coalition’s page states, “Due to the passage of H.R. 1, the top 1% of Vermont income earners are set to receive an average annual tax cut of $57,000, beginning in 2026.” The $57,000 figure for the top 1% of Vermonters is not a new tax cut. Rather, it represents the tax increase that high-income earners would have faced if the tax provisions of the 2017 TCJA had expired. H.R. 1 extended those existing tax provisions. The Institute for Economic Policy (ITEP) sent a note to the HWM committee correcting their testimony on that and it is here<https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20Ways%20and%20Means/Bills/DR%2026-0804/W~Miles%20Trinidad~Miles%20Trinidad%20Clarification~4-16-2026.pdf>. Note that the $25,000 in “business-side” tax cuts they reference relates to the OBBBA allowing businesses to claim expenses related to new equipment and research and development in the year the expenses occurred rather than having to prorate those expenses over a period of time. In other words, they are not simple tax "cuts." These provisions primarily change the timing of business tax deductions, not the amount of tax ultimately owed.



From: Connizzo, Katelyn <Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov<mailto:Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Friday, October 30, 2026 10:27 AM
To: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>; Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Subject: RE: Internal FW: Calvin request

I would suggest that in the name of refocusing on how we would like press communications to be channeled in the future it should come from the Commissioner’s inbox of possible (Maude is exempt, right?).

I would also suggest that we remove the third bullet from the initial email. Calvin’s question doesn’t seem to me to be about the balance of the op-ed, even if the op-ed may have influenced his writing on this particular point. He might clarify that he would like more on the $57k, in which case we can respond with what we have prepared here, but including the third bullet at this point feels unrelated and too defensive to me. The story we think he’s asking about doesn’t mention the $57k or the Department at all. My read on the request is that Public Assets doesn’t like the use of the verb “claw back” in the 10/21 story<https://www.wcax.com/news/2026/10/21/vermont-weighs-new-tax-high-earners-amid-budget-pressures/>, and Calvin would like to double up his fact checking on its usage.

Thanks so much,
Kate

Kate Connizzo (she/her)
Director of Communications and Organizational Development
Vermont Department of Taxes
133 State St, Montpelier, VT
[phone redacted]
tax.vermont.gov<https://tax.vermont.gov/>

From: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Friday, October 30, 2026 9:12 AM
To: Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>; Connizzo, Katelyn <Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov<mailto:Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Re: Internal FW: Calvin request

I’m going to have you review a few tweaks and extra sentences (for Calvin’s benefit) when I break from meetings over lunchtime. High level this is exactly what we needed!

Question for both of you –– do folks have a preference as to whether this email comes from a technocrat like Jake or another exempt appointee (me). Calvin hasn’t been part of the “should tax have been involved” question so maybe not an issue either way.

Get Outlook for iOS<https://aka.ms/o0ukef>
________________________________
From: Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Thursday, 29 October 2026 14:38:22
To: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>; Connizzo, Katelyn <Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov<mailto:Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Re: Internal FW: Calvin request

Here are some ideas on what to say back to Calvin. Maybe TMI or too technical


  *   In 2018, in response to the federal Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, the Legislature made Vermont's income tax more progressive, increasing taxes on filers with income over $100,000 by about $11M and decreasing taxes on filers under that by about $9M. A former analyst from the Joint Fiscal Office testified<https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20Ways%20and%20Means/Bills/DR%2026-0804/W~Graham%20Campbell~Tax%20Cut%20and%20Jobs%20Act,%20Retrospective%20and%20Lessons~4-21-2026.pdf#page=5> to that effect this past spring.


  *   Part of the justification for the tax increase at that time was the perception that the federal income taxes of the highest earning Vermonters were decreasing as a result of the TCJA. The tax impacts of the TCJA varied based on the taxpayer, but in many cases the new $10,000 limitation on the federal state and local income tax deduction (the "SALT" deduction) outstripped the value from the lower marginal rates. This was especially true in high tax states like Vermont. We explained<https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2018/WorkGroups/Senate%20Finance/Bills/H.911/H.911~Jake%20Feldman~Impacts%20to%20Vermont%20Taxpayers%20of%20the%20Tax%20Cuts%20and%20Jobs%20Act~4-6-2018.pdf> that and showed the math in committee


  *   We stand by the commissioner's op-ed stating that the $57,000 tax cut figure for the top 1% of Vermonters was not a new tax cut but in fact an extension of the 2017 TCJA. The Institute for Economic Policy (ITEP) sent a note to the committee correcting their testimony on that and it is here<https://legislature.vermont.gov/Documents/2026/Workgroups/House%20Ways%20and%20Means/Bills/DR%2026-0804/W~Miles%20Trinidad~Miles%20Trinidad%20Clarification~4-16-2026.pdf>.  The $25,000 in business side tax cuts they reference mostly has to do with the OBBBA allowing businesses to claim expenses related to new equipment and research and development in the year they occurred rather than having to prorate them. In other words, they are not tax "cuts" just changing of when the tax benefit occurs.


________________________________
From: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2026 12:10 PM
To: Connizzo, Katelyn <Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov<mailto:Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov>>; Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Subject: RE: Internal FW: Calvin request


(And YES great clarification, Kate! Poor use of the word quote.)



From: Connizzo, Katelyn <Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov<mailto:Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2026 11:05 AM
To: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>; Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Subject: RE: Internal FW: Calvin request



Just clarifying that it’s not a quote attributed to an individual. The sentence is part of the article unattributed. Realize that may have been what you meant in the first place!



Kate Connizzo (she/her)
Director of Communications and Organizational Development

Vermont Department of Taxes

133 State St, Montpelier, VT

[phone redacted]

tax.vermont.gov<https://tax.vermont.gov/>



From: Sameroff, Rebecca <Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov<mailto:Rebecca.Sameroff@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2026 11:00 AM
To: Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Cc: Connizzo, Katelyn <Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov<mailto:Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Internal FW: Calvin request



Hey Jake,



Let’s connect about handling the below question from Calvin. This ask refers to WCAX coverage that included a quote that’s likely based on Bill’s op-ed (which Calvin had access to from Sarah M). Likely this story<https://www.wcax.com/news/2026/10/21/vermont-weighs-new-tax-high-earners-amid-budget-pressures/> and this statement –  “Vermont lawmakers clawed back Trump administration tax cuts on the wealthy in 2018, and now some want to tax those higher earners again.”



I’m clear between 1130-1 and again around 3pm.



Fun.

Rebecca



From: Mearhoff, Sarah <Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov<mailto:Sarah.Mearhoff@vermont.gov>>
Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2026 10:22 AM
To: TAX - Commissioner <TAX.Commissioner@vermont.gov<mailto:TAX.Commissioner@vermont.gov>>
Cc: Connizzo, Katelyn <Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov<mailto:Katelyn.Connizzo@vermont.gov>>; Feldman, Jake <Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov<mailto:Jake.Feldman@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Calvin request



Good morning! Forwarding on some texts I got from WCAX’s Calvin Cutler this morning. Sounds like he could just use a conversation with someone on background or off the record to clarify that his story from last week doesn’t really need to be corrected…



Hey Sarah! I had a quick follow up question for you regarding the Fair Share proposal. I’m just now getting some pushback from public assets folks about our framing of the legislature clawing back some tax cuts in 2018. And the idea of it being a “new” tax versus “clawing back” tax cuts from HR1. Got a minute to chat at some point? Thanks!



No specific deadline- they are asking me to make changes 8 days after it aired, so I don’t get the se

Part of the Gazette's published records for A political message from the Tax Department, edited and cleared by the Governor's office, days before Scott stood for reelection and The Tax Commissioner directed state employees to write an op-ed based on Facebook memes. Why doesn’t Vermont have a ‘little Hatch Act’? and Did Governor Scott direct state employees to interfere in an election? Governor won't release records that could absolve him. All 151 files →