Public records · Emails · TXT

Cover email from Gilhuly, Chrissy

Nov 20, 2026, 12:38 PM EST · RE: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026 (Office of the Secretary of Administration)

Source
aoa1 cover email
Date
Nov 20, 2026, 12:38 PM EST
From
"Gilhuly, Chrissy" <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>
To
Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
File
aoa1-cover-email.txt · 19 KB
SHA-256
48a476c585a0eddd14469abb8bb90d2c5b186110f9a1362f0ab0bbe1609fb06e
From: "Gilhuly, Chrissy" <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>
To: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
Date: Fri, 20 Nov 2026 17:38:53 +0000
Subject:  RE: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026 (Office of the Secretary of Administration)

Dear Mr. Rkiouak,

Thank you for your patience and allowing for the extra day to respond to your request.

The Agency of Administration has completed its review of the records responsive to your request.
The Agency of Administration is withholding the responsive records pursuant to 1 V.S.A. § 317(c)(4), based on executive privilege. The records include communications involving the Governor, the Secretary of Administration, their respective senior staff, and Department of Taxes officials concerning tax policy and communications strategy.
Jaye Pershing Johnson, Legal Counsel to the Governor, is responsible for the determination to withhold these records. I consulted with Ms. Johnson in my capacity as records custodian in making this determination.
Pursuant to 1 V.S.A. § 318(a)(2), I certify that, as the records custodian, I consider the withheld materials to be exempt from public inspection. You have the right to appeal this determination to Sarah Clark, Secretary of Administration, in accordance with 1 V.S.A. § 318.

Sincerely,

Chrissy


Chrissy Gilhuly
Administrative Operations Manager
Agency of Administration - Office of the Secretary
109 State Street, 5th Floor | Montpelier, VT  05609-0201
802-828-3322 office


This e-mail, including attachments, is intended for the exclusive use of the addressee and may contain proprietary, confidential or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient, any dissemination, use, distribution or copying is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please notify me via return e-mail and permanently delete the original and destroy all copies.

From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, November 18, 2026 2:42 PM
To: Gilhuly, Chrissy <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>
Subject: Re: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026 (Office of the Secretary of Administration)

EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
Of course, my intent is not to be a burden on Vermont's government. A day delay is reasonable.

Regards,

Matt

On Wed, Nov 18, 2026 at 2:40 PM Gilhuly, Chrissy <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov<mailto:Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>> wrote:
Thank you for understanding, greatly appreciated.



Chrissy Gilhuly
Administrative Operations Manager
Agency of Administration - Office of the Secretary
109 State Street<https://www.google.com/maps/search/109+State+Street?entry=gmail&source=g>, 5th Floor | Montpelier, VT  05609-0201
802-828-3322<tel:(802)%20828-3322> office


This e-mail, including attachments, is intended for the exclusive use of the addressee and may contain proprietary, confidential or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient, any dissemination, use, distribution or copying is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please notify me via return e-mail and permanently delete the original and destroy all copies.

From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>>
Sent: Wednesday, November 18, 2026 2:40 PM
To: Gilhuly, Chrissy <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov<mailto:Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Re: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026 (Office of the Secretary of Administration)

EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
Ok, thank you for the message and I will look forward to receiving the records.

Regards,

Matt

On Wed, Nov 18, 2026, 2:38 PM Gilhuly, Chrissy <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov<mailto:Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>> wrote:
Good afternoon,

I am writing to request a one-business-day extension to respond to your public records request.

I apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your understanding. I will provide our response by Friday, November 20.

Thank you,
Chrissy




Chrissy Gilhuly
Administrative Operations Manager
Agency of Administration - Office of the Secretary
109 State Street<https://www.google.com/maps/search/109+State+Street?entry=gmail&source=g>, 5th Floor | Montpelier, VT  05609-0201
802-828-3322<tel:(802)%20828-3322> office


This e-mail, including attachments, is intended for the exclusive use of the addressee and may contain proprietary, confidential or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient, any dissemination, use, distribution or copying is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please notify me via return e-mail and permanently delete the original and destroy all copies.

From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>>
Sent: Monday, November 9, 2026 4:17 PM
To: Gilhuly, Chrissy <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov<mailto:Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>>
Subject: RE: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026 (Office of the Secretary of Administration)

You don't often get email from mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>. Learn why this is important<https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification>
EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
Ms. Gilhuly,

Thank you for the acknowledgement and the November 19 date.

The request is about the government's involvement in, and coordination around, the commentary. Items 1 through 4, 7 and 9 ask only for records concerning the commentary, and I cannot narrow them further without giving up records. I can make them easier to execute:

- Custodians: Secretary Clark, Deputy Secretary Brown, the Chief Communications Officer and the Deputy Chief Communications Officer, plus any other Office staff who handled the matter.

- Search terms, as an aid and not a limit: "op-ed", "op ed", "oped", "commentary", "Shouldice", "wealth tax", "57,000", "57k", "Fair Share", "Janoo", "surcharge", "progressive", "ITEP", "Public Assets", "Reddit".

- Order: items 1, 2, 3 and 9 first, on a rolling basis; the rest when ready.

Two clarifications, which limit items 6 and 8 to the commentary:

- Item 6: guidance issued or transmitted by the Secretary or the Office in 2026 on election-period communications or political activity, and its transmission to the Department of Taxes. Guidance the Office received from other agencies is not requested.

- Item 8: "the proposed income surcharge" means the surcharge on high incomes proposed by Amanda Janoo in the 2026 campaign, which the commentary addresses. Communications about the commentary, the $57,000 figure, the progressivity claim and that proposal are requested; general campaign traffic is not.

Item 5 stays as written: two weeks of calendar entries for meetings or calls with the Commissioner or Department staff, regardless of subject, because the records show the Office was involved before the first email.

If one item accounts for most of the volume, please tell me which one and roughly how many records it covers, and I will consider it.

Regards,

Matt Rkiouak
Middlesex, Vermont
mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>

On Mon, Nov 09, 2026 03:55 PM, "Gilhuly, Chrissy" <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov<mailto:Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>> wrote:
Good afternoon, Mr. Rkiouak,

I’m responding to your public records request.  Please know that we are making a good faith effort to complete your request as timely as possible and are currently in the process of pulling records.

Please also be advised that the Secretary of Administration’s office is not the custodian of any agency/department records other than of this office

Second, because your request will result in the need to search for, collect and appropriately examine a voluminous number of records responsive to your request, pursuant to 1 V.S.A. § 318(a)(5)(B), we will respond to
your request by November 19, 2026 (10 business days).

Finally, as you might know, 1 V.S.A. § 318(d) of the Open Record Law authorizes a public agency to request a person to narrow the scope, or be more specific, of a request for a voluminous number of records. I’m wondering if there is a way you can narrow your request so that we can be most responsive to your concerns.

All the best,
Chrissy Gilhuly
Records Officer


Chrissy Gilhuly
Administrative Operations Manager
Agency of Administration - Office of the Secretary
109 State Street<https://www.google.com/maps/search/109+State+Street?entry=gmail&source=g>, 5th Floor | Montpelier, VT  05609-0201
802-828-3322<tel:(802)%20828-3322> office


This e-mail, including attachments, is intended for the exclusive use of the addressee and may contain proprietary, confidential or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient, any dissemination, use, distribution or copying is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please notify me via return e-mail and permanently delete the original and destroy all copies.

From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>>
Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2026 7:13 PM
To: Gilhuly, Chrissy <Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov<mailto:Chrissy.Gilhuly@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026 (Office of the Secretary of Administration)

You don't often get email from mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>. Learn why this is important<https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification>
EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
November 5, 2026

Chrissy Gilhuly, Records Officer
Agency of Administration
Office of the Secretary of Administration
109 State Street<https://www.google.com/maps/search/109+State+Street+%0D%0AMontpelier,+VT+05609?entry=gmail&source=g>
Montpelier, VT 05609<https://www.google.com/maps/search/109+State+Street+%0D%0AMontpelier,+VT+05609?entry=gmail&source=g>
By email: chrissy.gilhuly@vermont.gov<mailto:chrissy.gilhuly@vermont.gov>

Re: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026

Dear Ms. Gilhuly:

Under the Public Records Act, 1 V.S.A. §§ 315–320, I request copies of the records of the Office of the Secretary of Administration described below. The Department of Taxes and the Office of the Governor have each received a separate request from me (October 30, 2026); this request is for the copies in the Office of the Secretary's own custody and its internal records, whether or not the Department or the Office of the Governor also holds a copy. It also covers the Agency's Communications and Marketing Office; if you are not that office's records officer, please forward this request to the person who is and tell me who that is.

DEFINITIONS

"The commentary" means the piece by Commissioner of Taxes Bill Shouldice posted on https://www.google.com/url?q=http://tax.vermont.gov&source=gmail&ust=1794010085636000&sa=E on October 27, 2026 under the title "Tax Commissioner Shouldice Challenges $57,000 Tax Cut Claim" and published as a commentary in the Manchester Journal (October 25), the Times Argus and Rutland Herald (October 27), the Brattleboro Reformer, the Caledonian Record and other papers, together with every draft, version, excerpt or adaptation of it, including social-media posts. "The Office" means the Secretary of Administration (Sarah Clark), the Deputy Secretary (Sean Brown) and any other person employed in or assigned to the Office of the Secretary of Administration during the period, together with the Agency's Chief Communications Officer and Deputy Chief Communications Officer. "The Department" means the Vermont Department of Taxes, including the Commissioner, the Deputy Commissioner, the Commissioner's principal assistant and the Department's communications staff. "Communications" means email, text and instant messages (SMS, iMessage, Teams, Slack, Signal, WhatsApp or similar), voicemail, calendar invitations and meeting notes, on any device or account used to conduct public business. Unless an item says otherwise, the period is October 1, 2026 through the date of your search.

RECORDS REQUESTED

1. All communications between the Office and the Department concerning the commentary: its conception, drafting, figures, review, edits, approval, timing, placement, publication, promotion or public reaction. This includes the Commissioner's email to the Secretary and Amanda Wheeler of October 19, 2026 at 8:00 PM and the Secretary's reply of October 20, 2026 at 7:36 AM, each as a message with its full headers and attachments.

2. Every draft, version, markup or set of edits of the commentary sent to or by the Office, with the message that carried it, in native format so that the file's metadata is preserved (§ 316(h)).

3. All communications between the Office and the Office of the Governor, including its press secretary, communications director and policy director, concerning the commentary. If executive privilege is asserted for any record, please identify each record, state whether the Governor personally sent or received it, and support the claim by the affidavit of the official who personally considered it (Killington, Ltd. v. Lash, 153 Vt. 628 (1990); New England Coalition v. Office of the Governor, 164 Vt. 337 (1995); Herald Ass'n v. Dean, 174 Vt. 350 (2002)). The privilege is qualified, reaches communications with the Governor in the course of his policy deliberations rather than communications among staff, and is distinct from the deliberative-process privilege that § 317(c)(4) withholds from Executive Branch agencies.

4. Communications within the Office concerning the commentary, including its timing relative to the October 21 Vermont Public debate and the November 3 election.

5. Calendar entries and meeting invitations for meetings or calls between the Secretary or Office staff and the Commissioner or Department staff, October 13 through October 27, 2026, and any call-history records the Office holds or can retrieve from its own State phones and Teams accounts. If the Office holds none, please certify that under § 318(b)(4) and name the agency that does.

6. Any policy, guidance or directive issued, received or transmitted in 2026 by the Secretary (including any Agency bulletin or memorandum over the Secretary's signature), the Office or the Communications and Marketing Office concerning communications during the election period — op-eds and commentaries, press releases, use of agency websites and social media, political activity or neutrality — and records of its transmission to the Department. If the Office holds no such record, please certify that under § 318(b)(4) and name the custodian that would.

7. Copies held by the Office of any request for, or provision of, guidance, interpretation or determination under Personnel Policy 5.7 (Political Activity) or Executive Order 04-22 (Executive Code of Ethics) concerning the commentary, whether made or received by the Office, the Department, the Secretary of Civil and Military Affairs or the Department of Human Resources, including any request to or advice from the Attorney General's office, and any complaint the Office received about the commentary together with the Office's response. If attorney-client privilege or § 317(c)(7) is asserted, please identify each withheld record as § 318(b)(2) requires and produce the non-privileged portions, including dates, senders and recipients, as § 318(e) requires; if the Office holds nothing, please certify that under § 318(b)(4).

8. Communications between the Office and any campaign, political committee or party, including the Governor's reelection committee, concerning the commentary, the "$57,000" federal tax-cut figure, the claim that Vermont has the most, or one of the most, progressive tax systems in the country, or the proposed income surcharge. If no responsive record exists, please certify so in writing under § 318(b)(4). If the Office concludes that a communication with a campaign, committee or party about these subjects exists but is not a public record, please say so in writing, identify it by date and participants, and state the basis, so that I may appeal under § 318(c).

9. Records sufficient to show who in the Office reviewed, cleared or approved the commentary, in what form, and when. The messages and drafts produced under items 1 and 2 may satisfy this item; if no other record shows review or approval, please say so under § 318(b)(4).

SCOPE AND FORMAT

- Public records are within the Act wherever they are kept, including personal email, messaging and social-media accounts, when they were produced or acquired in the course of public agency business (1 V.S.A. § 317(b); Toensing v. Attorney General, 2017 VT 99, ¶¶ 12, 22). Because items 1, 3, 4 and 8 seek specified communications to or from named officials, please ask each person within the definition of "the Office" to provide any responsive public records from such accounts and to describe how they searched (id. ¶¶ 24, 34, 36; Executive Order 04-22, § III.A(11)), and tell me what each reported; where no responsive record is found, please certify that under § 318(b)(4).

- Please provide electronic copies in the standard electronic format under § 316(h)–(i), that is, the format in which each record is maintained: for email, the message as exported from the mail system with its headers and attachments; for documents, the native file. Rolling production is welcome; items 1, 2 and 9 first.

- Please preserve all potentially responsive records, including text and instant messages, while this request is pending (1 V.S.A. § 317a).

- Please provide an estimate before incurring staff-time charges beyond the first 30 minutes (§ 316(c)). If the estimate exceeds $100, please contact me before proceeding; I may narrow the request or elect to inspect records rather than take copies.

- If any record is withheld in whole or in part, please provide the certification § 318(b)(2) requires — identifying the records withheld, the statutory basis and a brief statement of the reasons and supporting facts, the names and titles or positions of those responsible, and notice of the right to appeal — and redact and produce the remainder of each record as § 318(e) requires. Under § 317(c)(4) the common-law deliberative-process privilege "as it applies to ... the Executive Branch agencies of the State of Vermont" is not a basis for withholding, so drafts and internal deliberations are not exempt on that ground.

- Please respond within three business days of receipt (§ 318(a)–(b)). If you invoke an extension under § 318(b)(5), please state the reasons and the date on which you expect to dispatch a determination, which may be no later than ten business days from receipt.

Sincerely,

Matt Rkiouak
Middlesex, Vermont
mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com> · [phone redacted]<tel:(781)%20492-8024>

Part of the Gazette's published records for A political message from the Tax Department, edited and cleared by the Governor's office, days before Scott stood for reelection and The Tax Commissioner directed state employees to write an op-ed based on Facebook memes. Why doesn’t Vermont have a ‘little Hatch Act’? and Did Governor Scott direct state employees to interfere in an election? Governor won't release records that could absolve him. All 151 files →