Public records · Emails · TXT

Cover email from Pallas, Karen

Nov 19, 2026, 12:51 PM EST · FW: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026

Source
gov1 cover email
Date
Nov 19, 2026, 12:51 PM EST
From
"Pallas, Karen" <Karen.Pallas@vermont.gov>
To
"mrkiouak@gmail.com" <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
File
gov1-cover-email.txt · 10 KB
SHA-256
9f2a71335381720da9e6eef06e9321b47143c74c352630f111bf411a4738df46
From: "Pallas, Karen" <Karen.Pallas@vermont.gov>
To: "mrkiouak@gmail.com" <mrkiouak@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2026 17:51:10 +0000
Subject:  FW: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026

Dear Mr. Rkiouak



My apologies for the delay. Please know that it was not our intent to deny your request.



With that said, in response to your request below, except as set forth herein, attached please find all records responsive to your request.



Certain records have been withheld to the extent they are exempt from disclosure under 1 V.S.A. § 317(c)(4) as executive privileged. This includes those records between the Governor, the Governor’s Senior Staff and Tax Department officials with respect to tax policy and communications strategy.



I conferred with Jaye Pershing Johnson, the Governor's Legal Counsel, when making the determination to redact or withhold information.



As the records custodian, I certify, as required by 1 V.S.A. § 318(a)(2), that I consider the redacted materials to be exempt from disclosure. You have the right to appeal, as explained in 1 V.S.A. § 318, to Jason Gibbs, Chief of Staff, relative to my certification of the records as exempt.



Sincerely,

Karen Pallas

Records Officer


From: Pallas, Karen
Sent: Wednesday, November 4, 2026 4:42 PM
To: mrkiouak@gmail.com
Subject: FW: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026
Importance: High

Good Afternoon Mr. Rkiouak–

This email is to again confirm receipt of your public records request below.  Please know that we are making a good faith effort to complete your request as timely as possible and are in the process of searching for any records.

Because your request has resulted in the need to search for, collect and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of records responsive to your request and has resulted in the need for consultation with another agency having a substantial interest in the determination of the request, pursuant to 1 V.S.A. § 318(a)(5)(B) and 1 V.S.A. § 318(a)(5)(C), we will respond to your request within 10 business days (November 13, 2026).

As also stated below, the Governor’s Office is not the custodian of records other than of this office. For other agencies/departments/elected officials you will need to reach out to them directly.

Best,
Karen Pallas
Records Officer


From: Pallas, Karen
Sent: Friday, October 30, 2026 3:01 PM
To: 'mrkiouak@gmail.com' <mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>>
Subject: FW: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026

Good Afternoon Mr. Rkiouak

This email is to confirm receipt of your public records request below and we are processing your request.

Please be advised that the Governor’s Office is not the custodian of records other than of this office. For other offices/agencies/departments/elected officials you will need to reach out to them directly.

Best,
Karen Pallas
Records Officer

From: Matthew Rkiouak <mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>>
Sent: Friday, October 30, 2026 10:06 AM
To: Pallas, Karen <Karen.Pallas@vermont.gov<mailto:Karen.Pallas@vermont.gov>>
Subject: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026

You don't often get email from mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com>. Learn why this is important<https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification>
EXTERNAL SENDER: Do not open attachments or click on links unless you recognize and trust the sender.
October 30, 2026

Karen Pallas, Records Officer
Office of Governor Phil Scott
109 State Street
Montpelier, VT 05609
By email: Karen.Pallas@vermont.gov<mailto:Karen.Pallas@vermont.gov>

Re: Public records request — Department of Taxes commentary of October 25–27, 2026

Dear Ms. Pallas:

Under the Public Records Act, 1 V.S.A. §§ 315–320, I request copies of the records of the Office of the Governor described below.

DEFINITIONS

"The commentary" means the piece by Commissioner of Taxes Bill Shouldice posted on on October 27, 2026 under the title "Tax Commissioner Shouldice Challenges $57,000 Tax Cut Claim"<https://tax.vermont.gov/blog/tax-commissioner-shouldice-challenges-57000-tax-cut-claim> and published as a commentary in the Manchester Journal (October 25), the Times Argus and Rutland Herald (October 27), the Brattleboro Reformer and the Caledonian Record, together with every draft, version, excerpt or adaptation of it, including social-media posts. "The Office" means the Governor and the staff of the Office of the Governor, including the Chief of Staff and deputies, the Communications Director and press staff, the Secretary of Civil and Military Affairs, legal counsel, policy advisers and schedulers. "The campaign" means the Governor's reelection committee (Phil Scott for Vermont, or however it is currently styled), its staff, consultants and volunteers, including its spokesperson, Emma Shouldice. "Communications" means email, text and instant messages (SMS, iMessage, Teams, Slack, Signal, WhatsApp or similar), voicemail, calendar invitations and meeting notes, on any device or account used to conduct public business. Unless an item says otherwise, the period is October 1, 2026 through the date of your search.

RECORDS REQUESTED

1. All communications between the Office and the Department of Taxes — including Commissioner Shouldice, the Deputy Commissioner and the Department's communications staff — concerning the commentary: its conception, drafting, figures, review, approval, timing, placement, publication, promotion or public reaction.

2. Every draft or version of the commentary held by the Office, with file metadata, and any edits, suggested language, talking points or messaging documents the Office provided to the Department for it.

3. Communications within the Office concerning the commentary, including its timing relative to the October 21 Vermont Public debate and the November 3 election.

4. Communications between the Office and the campaign, the Vermont Republican Party or any political committee concerning: the commentary; the "$57,000" federal tax-cut figure; the claim that Vermont has the most, or one of the most, progressive tax systems in the country; or Amanda Janoo's proposed income surcharge.

5. Debate-preparation, briefing or messaging documents held by the Office that reference the $57,000 figure, Vermont's tax-progressivity ranking or the proposed surcharge (October 1–27, 2026), and records showing whether any were shared with, or received from, the Department of Taxes.

6. Any policy, guidance or directive issued in 2026 by the Office or the Agency of Administration to agencies, departments or appointees concerning communications during the election period — op-eds and commentaries, press releases, use of agency websites and social media, political activity or neutrality — and records of its transmission to the Department of Taxes.

7. Records of any request for, or provision of, guidance, interpretation or determination under Executive Order 04-22 (Executive Code of Ethics) concerning the commentary, including by the Secretary of Civil and Military Affairs, and any complaint the Office received about the commentary together with the Office's response. If attorney-client privilege is asserted, please identify each withheld record as § 318(b)(2) requires and produce the non-privileged portions, including dates, senders and recipients.

8. Calendar entries, meeting invitations and call logs for meetings or calls between the Governor or Office staff and Commissioner Shouldice or Department of Taxes communications staff, October 14–27, 2026.

9. Records of any Office sign-off or clearance process for commentaries or op-eds by gubernatorial appointees as applied to this commentary; approval emails or tickets will suffice.

SCOPE AND FORMAT

- Public records held in personal email, messaging or social-media accounts are within the Act when they concern public business (Toensing v. Attorney General, 2017 VT 99). Because campaign contact commonly runs through personal phones, please ask each custodian covered by items 1, 3 and 4 to search such accounts for responsive records and to confirm in writing that they have done so.

- Please provide electronic copies in the format in which each record is maintained (§ 316(h)–(i)): emails with full headers and attachments, documents in native format with metadata. Rolling production is welcome; items 1, 2 and 4 first.

- Please preserve all potentially responsive records, including text and instant messages, from the date you receive this request.

- Please provide an estimate before incurring staff-time charges beyond the first 30 minutes (§ 316(c)). If the estimate exceeds $100, please contact me before proceeding; I may narrow the request or elect to inspect records rather than take copies.

- If the Office withholds any record under 1 V.S.A. § 317(c)(4) on the basis of executive privilege (Killington, Ltd. v. Lash, 153 Vt. 628 (1990)), please identify each record by date, author, recipients and subject as § 318(b)(2) requires, state whether the Governor personally sent or received it, and produce the segregable portions as § 318(e) requires. Communications with the campaign, with media outlets, and with the Department about placement and promotion are not policy advice to the Governor and are requested in full. Section 317(c)(4) does not extend the deliberative-process privilege to Executive Branch agencies.

- If any other record is withheld in whole or in part, please provide the § 318(b)(2) certification — the records withheld, the statutory basis and reasons, the names and titles of those responsible, and notice of the right to appeal — and redact and produce the remainder of each record.

- Please acknowledge receipt and respond within three business days (§ 318(a)). If you invoke an extension under § 318(b)(5), please state the reasons and the date you expect to produce.

Sincerely,

Matt Rkiouak
Middlesex, Vermont
mrkiouak@gmail.com<mailto:mrkiouak@gmail.com> · [phone redacted]

Part of the Gazette's published records for A political message from the Tax Department, edited and cleared by the Governor's office, days before Scott stood for reelection and The Tax Commissioner directed state employees to write an op-ed based on Facebook memes. Why doesn’t Vermont have a ‘little Hatch Act’? and Did Governor Scott direct state employees to interfere in an election? Governor won't release records that could absolve him. All 151 files →